Club Meeting, Bates Cup Pdi Competition - Tuesday 4th April 2023.



            1st. Dunstanburgh.                       2nd. Shelf Cloud, Ribblehead.              3rd. Black becomes Green.
On Tuesday 4th April Morpeth Camera Club welcomed, via Zoom, Richard Spiers DPAGB APAGB BPE2, from Carlisle
to hear his comments and to announce the results of the Annual Bates Cup Landscape Competition. The judge began
by saying that he was stating his individual preferences; that another judge might say something different, adding
that photography is an art form and therefore totally subjective.
Taken in a wide variety of locations, the 57 entries included the Fairy Pools, a Cuillin View, Neist Point and, Old Man
of Storr on the Isle of Skye, sweeping vistas of Blea Tarn and local scenes of the Breamish Valley, at Dunstanburgh,
Druridge Bay, Ladyburn Lake, Shaftoe Crags, Sycamore Gap, Cary Burn, and College Valley.
We saw stunningly colourful poppy fields which contrasted with a dramatic monochrome Raasay Pier together with
lovely scenes of Lochranza, Loch Tay, Duncansby Stacks and Portsoy. Entries of further afield were a night time scene
of the Garonne River and of the vibrant blue steamy mist at Yellowstone National Park.
Richard stated that the best landscapes are not always captured on bright sunny days, that cloud and mist adds
atmosphere. He pointed out that in many images submitted; a good foreground had provided grounding. He added
that a tree for instance, is traditionally placed on the thirds of the scene, but rules can be broken and it depends on
what suits the subject. He pointed out that in most landscape competitions prominent figures should not be included,
but an occasional person, to add scale may be allowed.
Dramatic cloudscapes, a gritty monochrome urban scene, intentional camera movement creations, silhouetted pylons
at sunset, calm and stormy seascapes were also among the images submitted. Throughout the evening he offered
advice on cropping to reveal where the scene should stop, the adjustment of shadows and highlights, advised the
use of digital graduated filters to enhance dull skies and on changing the viewpoint and cloning out distractions.
He said that Morpeth Camera Club always came up with good composition and he wasn’t disappointed in the entries
this evening, after which he went on to announce his four Highly Commended Images. Allt Derg, Isle of Skye by
Graham Sorrie, Pentland Hills by Roseanne Robinson, The Ash Twins by Paul Appleby and Snowdrops by John Barnes.
In fifth place was Cove, by Jeremy Cooper, for its brilliant light, focus, detail and information. In fourth place was
Carl Harper with The Side Pike for its well handled light, in third place was Andrew Flounders with Black Becomes
Green, a seascape with a great foreground, in second place was Paul Appleby with Shelf Cloud at Ribblehead,
which the judge said, had been captured well and which had provided so much information. Richard announced
the winner of the 2023 Bates Cup Landscape Competition to be Jeremy Cooper with Dunstanburgh. Waves crashing
to the shore with Dunstanburgh Castle on the horizon, the judge said that it had wonderful lighting, that there was
nothing wasted in the space and was a cracking image.
Co Chair Sue Dawson thanked Richard for his detailed appraisal and for making it a successful on line meeting.